Both of my children, blessed or cursed with vivid
imaginations, struggled with movies in their preschool years. They’d fall into
the movie, totally immersed in the story and its outcome. Any dubious outcome
stressed them out, so I searched high and low to find
low-suspense movies for them in those years.
With Little A. a newborn and Big A. traveling for work
again, I really, really needed three-year-old S. to watch the occasional video.
Don’t judge me. Dinner and a movie for her meant I could feed Little A. and eat
my own dinner, too. Win-win-win.
So I tried her on all the lightweight Disney films I could
think of—I mean, Cinderella has no
bad guys, really. Right? It’s not the legendary source of endless children’s
traumas, like Snow White or Bambi. Nope. She wouldn’t go for Cinderella. I tried movie after movie.
Finally, she asked to see the Dumbo video
we’d inherited from a friend. I had never seen the film, so I just gave thanks
for my good fortune and popped in the cassette.
Well, if you have seen Dumbo,
then I don’t need to say anymore. If you haven’t, well…it’s not my favorite
movie of all time. So many aspects of that movie, while perhaps standard when
it was made, are just…profoundly troubling to me. On top of ALL kinds of bullying,
including “adults” bullying a child, this stunning children’s film includes an
imprisoned mother, nefarious scheming, surreptitious drinking, hallucinations,
racial stereotypes, and a disturbing look into the treatment of circus workers
and animals in the past.
And my determined three-year-old daughter picked THIS movie
to love over all others. She asked for THIS movie every time Big A. traveled
for work…which was about once a week that year. And so I watched it far more
times than I ever wanted. And she watched it far more times that I wanted her
to, which worried me. What would she make
of all that…stuff?
And yet, nearly nine years later, it occurs to me that maybe
I owe Dumbo after all.
My daughter’s confidence leaves me in awe. Her amazing personal
integrity gives her a rare natural acceptance of others. She’s literally so
comfortable with herself (in most ways; no one’s perfect) that she just appreciates
other people as they come. Okay, I hope some of that comes from her parents’
unending and unconditional love. I know her first school overtly encouraged
students to love and appreciate each other in all their differences. And I give
credit to her current school, where peer pressure reinforces individuality.
But, you know, Dumbo gets seriously dumped on from the
moment of his birth. Yet the movie makes it clear that he, his mother, and
Timothy have the right idea—Dumbo’s awesome. He rocks, no matter what anyone else says or does.
Best of all, Dumbo doesn’t have to prove anything to anyone
but himself to succeed. Without even speaking a word, he finds his “wings” and soars. His unique abilities have value; he learns that without devaluing
anyone else.
Maybe that’s not such a bad message to be exposed to over
and over in your formative years.